InvestorPlace Blogs is powered by Marketocracy. Marketocracy has authorized Investor Place Blogs as an official registrar for voting through Marketocracy's Investment Research Rating service. Registered members of InvestorPlace Blogs are linked with a Marketocracy account to establish voting power based on their performance of trading and posting on stocks.
A few days ago Strategy Lab posted another Question of the Week: In looking at the most widely held and most bought stocks in the Strategy Lab Open this week, we see Apple duking it out with Research In Motion - a clear case of the momentum buyers (AAPL) vs. the bargain hunters (RIMM). Which approach do you favor, and why? Give us some examples from your portfolio.
Personally, I want the best of all worlds and search for a growth company with stock price rising fast but still at a bargain value.
I think both AAPL and RIMM could be called "Momentum". Financially, they almost look like twins to me except that the price for RIMM (bargain) is generally up twice as much as AAPL (momentum)! Compare the following figures (mostly from finance.yahoo.com.):
Supposedly representing a Bargain Stock.
RIMM - Research in Motion (46B mkt.cap.)
Top and bottom line up. Good balance sheet.
Style characterized at Marketocracy as "Large Cap Growth".
PEG Ratio (5 yr expected): 1.55 (lower is better)
Price/Sales (ttm): 13.19 (lower is better)
Price/Book (mrq): 16.88 (lower is better)
(This is a high-tech company so price-to-book is not too meaningful.)
Return on Assets (ttm): 19.50% (higher is better)
Return on Equity (ttm): 29.72% (higher is better)
Stock Price Pct from 200d MA is Up 43.29%. Pct from 50d MA is Up 9.02%.
Stock Price Pct from Yr Low is Up 219.55%. Pct from Yr High is Down 3.87%.
Supposedly representing a Momentum Stock.
AAPL -- Apple Inc. (121B mkt.cap.)
Top and bottom line up. Good balance sheet.
Style characterized at Marketocracy as "Large Cap Growth".
PEG Ratio (5 yr expected): 1.56 (lower is better)
Price/Sales (ttm): 5.24 (lower is better)
Price/Book (mrq): 8.83 (lower is better)
(This is a high-tech company so price-to-book is not too meaningful.)
Return on Assets (ttm): 14.18% (higher is better)
Return on Equity (ttm): 27.57% (higher is better)
Stock Price Pct from 200d MA is Up 22.20%. Pct from 50d MA is Up 7.36%.
Stock Price Pct from Yr Low is Up 94.06%. Pct from Yr High is Down 5.39%.
I wouldn't have characterized either of the above as a "bargain" stock, especially not RIMM with a price-to-sales ratio of 13.19. Both do have a 5-year expected PEG Ratio under 2, which is supposed to be OK, but not under 1 which is supposed to be good. Both have a lower PEG Ratio than my stock PKX but higher than my CHL (see below). In the Value area, both have what I think is a good return on assets and return on equity, much better than PKX; however CHL is competitive. On the other hand, I'm not an expert in any of the subject industries; so don't take my word for what is a good ROA or ROE.
Following are examples of my attempt at finding a growth company which also has good value and a rising stock price.
POSCO (PKX) (47B mkt. cap.)
Top line up, bottom holding even. Good balance sheet.
Style characterized at Marketocracy as "Large Cap Growth".
PEG Ratio (5 yr expected): 1.89 (lower is better)
Price/Sales (ttm): 1.75 (lower is better)
Price/Book (mrq): N/A at Yahoo. 1.97 per my own calculation. (lower is better)
(This is a steel company so price-to-book is meaningful.)
Return on Assets (ttm): 9.33% (higher is better)
Return on Equity (ttm): 16.01% (higher is better)
Stock Price Pct from 200d MA is Up 24.43%. Pct from 50d MA is Up 7.76%.
Stock Price Pct from Yr Low is Up 144.31%. Pct from Yr High is Down 3.88%.
China Mobile Limited (CHL) (268B mkt. cap.)
Top line up, bottom line up. Good balance sheet.
Style characterized at Marketocracy as "Large Cap Value".
PEG Ratio (5 yr expected): 1.00 (lower is better)
Price/Sales (ttm): 6.34 (lower is better)
Price/Book (mrq): 6.03 (lower is better)
(This is a cell phone company so price to book may not be meaningful.)
Return on Assets (ttm): 14.26% (higher is better)
Return on Equity (ttm): 23.21% (higher is better)
Stock Price Pct from 200d MA is Up 32.29%. Pct from 50d MA is Up 14.65%.
Stock Price Pct from Yr Low is Up 106.60%. Pct from Yr High is Down 2.21%.
Maybe it is impossible to absolutely pigeonhole any individual company or stock or style of investing.
|