InvestorPlace Blogs is powered by Marketocracy. Marketocracy has authorized Investor Place Blogs as an official registrar for voting through Marketocracy's Investment Research Rating service. Registered members of InvestorPlace Blogs are linked with a Marketocracy account to establish voting power based on their performance of trading and posting on stocks.
Are marine transportation companies still hot or are they now over-valued? In spite of getting in late on this industry, I hoped to find a decently-priced stock in the field. Back in October Eagle Bulk Shipping (EGLE) showed up in one of my experimental screenings; however, price to sales (ttm) was 12.41 (higher than I like) and many candidates surpassed it in other areas, too.
Looking at competitors to the recently popular Dryships (DRYS), Excel Maritime Carriers (EXM), then at the competitors to competitors, I found 21 shipping companies: NPTOY.PK, HUWHY.PK, CKH, DAC, DRYS, DSX, EGLE, ESEA, EXM, FRO, GMR, GNK, NM, OCNF, OSG, PRGN, QMAR, RAMS, SSW, TDW, TK, TNP, TRMA, TRMD. (The first two tickers were immediately ruled out because they are on the pink sheets.)
Are there really no outstanding deals left within this group? I decided to compare company figures to their industry as well as to the market in general. Yahoo shows the following industry averages:
Qtrly. Rev. Growth (yoy), 14.00%
P/E (ttm), 15.90
PEG (5 yr expected), 1.39
P/S (ttm), 4.25
Well, those statistics look like reasonable value. But where did they come from? Many of the shipping companies had "NA" for various data. Plus, the 5-yr. estimated PEG always makes me nervous. Who is making that projection, anyway?
I decided to make an Excel spreadsheet for all companies listing the above data plus 3 more columns: price-to-book, CAPS rating and stock price trend. Ten stocks went to the bottom of the heap immediately because prices were down, flat or squirrily. A few more (including the aforementioned EGLE) did not have the very top year-over-year growth rate. For the rest, I looked for low Pr/Bk, low Pr/Sls and 9 to 30 P/E combined with low projected 5yr PEG.
DRYS and EXM were close runners-up in spite of people saying they may no longer be the deal they were. The "Finalists" were QMAR, ESEA, DSX, and NM. In addition, I tentatively kept PRGN. This is a very new Greek company with few figures showing up at Yahoo; however it has received favorable writeups and has a CAPS of 4. As it turned out, neither PRGN nor NM shows up at Marketocracy under the correct company name. That left only Quintana Maritime (QMAR), Diana Shipping (DSX) and Euroseas (ESEA).
In my StrategyLab Fund I recently sold Jones Lang LaSalle (JLL), which was still down in spite of the fact that it is bargain priced, is growing, and does a lot of business OUTSIDE the US. This left me with about $70,000 to invest; so rather than try to decide among the remaining 3 companies I simply bought $20K of each.
May they and their stocks sail onward!
|